Playing as a shortstop in MLB The Show 25 can be one of the most exciting and dynamic experiences in Road to the Show (RTTS). The position demands speed, precision, and the ability to impact the game on both sides of the ball. However, the team you land on has a huge effect on how quickly your player reaches the majors. Choosing a team with an established star at shortstop can stall your progress, while joining a team with a weaker infield option might open the door to a call-up within your first season.

For players who don't want to leave their fate in the hands of the draft, hand-picking the right organization is a smart move. Below, we'll break down some of the best teams to join as a shortstop in MLB The Show 25, considering roster needs, surrounding talent, and long-term opportunities. Along the way, we'll also look at how managing your resources, especially MLB 25 Stubs, can help accelerate your path to stardom.

Atlanta Braves

If you're looking for the best overall balance between early playing time and championship contention, the Atlanta Braves are the ideal landing spot. Despite being one of the strongest teams in MLB The Show 25, their shortstop situation is surprisingly weak. Orlando Arcia, the current starter, sits in the low-70 overall range, which leaves plenty of room for a rising prospect to step in.

The beauty of joining Atlanta is that you won't be carrying the team on your own. With Ronald Acuña Jr. in the outfield, Matt Olson at first, and Austin Riley anchoring third base, you'll have a powerful supporting cast around you from day one. That depth means playoff contention is almost guaranteed, giving you the thrill of postseason baseball early in your career.

The only risk is that the Braves could trade for or sign a higher-rated shortstop while you're still developing in the minors. If that happens, you might need to ask your agent to pursue a trade. Still, for most players, the Braves represent a near-perfect choice.

Arizona Diamondbacks

For players who don't mind waiting a bit longer before stepping into the majors, the Arizona Diamondbacks offer an intriguing option. Geraldo Perdomo, their current shortstop, sits in the mid-to-high 70s overall. That makes him a tougher player to overtake immediately, but it also ensures that when you do make the jump, you'll be more developed and better prepared for MLB competition.

Arizona's roster is well-balanced across the board, with Ketel Marte, Corbin Carroll, and Corbin Burnes giving the team both offensive and pitching strength. That structure allows you to grow without feeling the weight of carrying the franchise too soon. By the time your player arrives in the majors, the Diamondbacks will likely still be in contention, and you'll be ready to make a big impact.

This is also a great landing spot if you want to spend some time in the minors upgrading perks and attributes with your earned rewards. Investing MLB The Show 25 Stubs in training sessions, perks, or equipment boosts can help you hit the majors at a much higher level.

Milwaukee Brewers

If your goal is to crack an MLB roster as quickly as possible, look no further than the Milwaukee Brewers. Their starting shortstop, Andruw Monasterio, has an overall rating in the low-60s, which makes him one of the weakest everyday players at the position in the game. For an ambitious rookie, this presents an incredible opportunity to jump straight into the majors, potentially in your very first season.

The Brewers also boast a roster filled with defensive talent and speed, led by players like Christian Yelich and William Contreras. This means you won't be stranded on a struggling team once you arrive in the big leagues. To maximize your chances of getting called up quickly, prioritize spending your early training tokens on attribute upgrades instead of perks. Boosting key attributes like fielding, contact, and speed will raise your overall faster, giving you an edge over Monasterio almost immediately.

If you need extra boosts, using MLB 25 Stubs to acquire equipment upgrades or batting perks can shave valuable time off your journey. This is the most straightforward path to the majors for a shortstop.

Seattle Mariners

For players who want a balanced challenge, the Seattle Mariners are another solid team to consider. Their shortstop situation isn't as weak as Milwaukee's, but it still leaves room for competition. The Mariners boast a strong pitching rotation led by George Kirby and a solid core of hitters like Cal Raleigh and Julio Rodríguez (in the outfield), giving you a chance to grow within a contending environment.

The Mariners may not provide the fastest call-up opportunity, but their well-rounded roster ensures you won't waste years on a rebuilding team. Instead, you'll be part of a franchise that consistently pushes for playoff spots, and once you secure your place at shortstop, you'll have the chance to shine on the biggest stage.

Final Thoughts

No matter which team you choose, remember that success in Road to the Show isn't just about your on-field performance, it's also about how you manage your progression. Spending time wisely in training, choosing perks that fit your playstyle, and making smart investments with MLB The Show 25 Stubs all play major roles in how quickly you rise through the ranks.

Shortstop is a demanding position, but it's also one of the most rewarding in MLB The Show 25. By carefully picking your landing spot and backing it up with smart development choices, you can carve out a Hall of Fame career while enjoying every step of the grind. Whether you want the fastest path to the majors, a balanced long-term development route, or the thrill of competing for a championship, there's a perfect team out there waiting for you.